The Sunday Show

Sunday March 09, 2003 21:27

by S Aerobics - Oxygen to Info

RTE Radio1

Interviewed - Philip Knightly, journalist and author of the 'The First Casualty', a 150 year history of war corresponding, the struggle between journalists and the military. Kate Adi ; BBC war correspondent. Chris Hodges ; New York Times war correspondent. Conor Brady ; former editor of the Irish Times.

You can listen to the programme at
www.rte.ie/audio/sundayshow.ra

Here's a synopsis without some of the waffle ;

Problems facing journalists/spread of free information.

The Pentagon has threatened it may find it necessary to bomb areas in which war correspondents are attempting to report from the Iraqi side.

Censorship - the Pentagon intends to control airwave access, targetting journalists 'up links' and use of satellite phones in Iraq.

Great Opportunities !

The Pentagon has set up programmes for journalists to train with the military (1 week boyscout jamboree camps).
Good for PR and "initiates the reporters into the fraternity, bonding them with units, making them feel..."

The Pentagon has decreed that around 500 journalists (about 100 from non-US media) will be "embedded" within units of the US military.

"The military learned from the last Gulf war that their media restrictions were so severe that they couldn't get their own message out - so what we're seeing is a wider dissemination of the news the Pentagon wants you to see"

"The press is part of the problem, it is not just the military, the press wants to be part of the war effort, wants to do their bit and that includes disseminating the propaganda that is handed to them."

Its not all doom n' gloom

Internet alternative, e-mails for co-ordinating protests etc...

"Al-Jazeera is a very important factor in the whole broadcast network... log on to get the other side of the story"
English version www.cursor.org/aljazeera.htm

Check www.iraqjournal.org

The programme mainly focussed on the American media, not much mention of the Irish media.
We're good at analysing other countries problems but the picture isn't so clear when it's closer to home.
Anyone got info. on RTETV3TG4 correspondents in Iraq, are any Irish journalists "embedded" ?

save preference

Comments (2 of 2)

Don't have info but...

by AL

Mon Mar 10, 2003 11:29

we can safely assume that, as before, the Foreign News Department at RTE will get their information and images from Reuters, BBC, CNN and to a lesser degree, WTN. So in effect those who are going with the military will supply the main flow of 'news'.

Not a great debate -lots left out

by Terry

Mon Mar 10, 2003 13:53

I heard most of the debate and it was pretty poor. As for Kate Adi, she sold herself out
during the Gulf War I with her mum & pop stories from the troops. In the debate, about the
strongest thing she says is that the Pentagon are controlling the reports. Heck they were
doing that the last time and she never complained. She doesn't even seem to see the point that
if all the journalist spend their time with the troops, how on earth can they possibly reflect
what is going on. She seems totally unaware, that if you spend the whole war with the troops
that it is extremely likely you will engage in self censorship.

There is very little mention of the propaganda in the buildup to the Gulf War I, particularly
the lies that were undercovered on a number of keys issues.

There are a lot more holes that could be picked in this so called debate.

Upcoming Events

New Events

Other Press

User Preferences

Feeds

Blog Feeds

Anti-Empire

The Saker

Public Inquiry

Human Rights in Ireland

The Sunday Show

Comments (2 of 2)